Battle Royale! Ratings vs Flags: The Lightroom Deathmatch


Thanks to Joe Collins for his submission! Great stuff Joe! Check his work out at:

Taking thousands of photos brings unique challenges. Lightroom gives you nice options for keeping your photos organized. But organizing your photos takes some work. A system helps your get the most out of the digital asset management capabilities of Lightroom.

Snapping 1500 photos on a vacation or shoot is easy to do. But no one wants to see all of these photos! (Please don’t make anyone sit through this slideshow.)

In order to find your good stuff easily, you need to have a system. The most important thing about having a system is remaining consistent. Each unique way of organizing photos has merits. Find the best approach that works for you.

Pick and Reject Flags:

This is one of the easiest ways to cull and process your photos. Lightroom gives you two flags. If it looks like there are 3 flags it because it there is also the non-flag flag… which is to mark something as unflaged.

Some people find the 6 choices of star rating too many to handle. (0 star is an option.) If you find yourself laboring over whether something is 2 stars or 3 stars, flags are for you.

The Reject Flag (Lightroom Keybord shortcut = X) marks the file for deletion. It grays out the photo and you can remove the rejected photos later.

There is also the Pick Flag (Lightroom Keyboard shortcut = P). Use the Pick Flag to mark good photos.

For truly terrible photos, reject them. For OK photos, do nothing. For good photos, pick them. To see your good photos, sort by the Pick flag.

Pros: This is a super easy system and allows you to quickly find good photos and get rid of bad ones.

Cons: It is very binary in that a photo is either great or OK.

Star Ratings and Keywords:

This is the opposite extreme. The system takes more time but makes it much easier to find the best photo for the moment.

Decide in advance what your stars mean to you. Also use the Reject flag. Here is an example:

1 Star: Looked at the photo and it was good enough not to delete. 2 Stars: Good photo that I would show someone and would spend time editing. 3 Stars: Great photo that I want to add to my larger portfolio. 4 Stars: My very best photos. 5 Stars: My top top photos.

In this system, the vast majority of your photos should be 1 star. I like marking every photo with 1 star because I want to know that I have at least looked and processed every photo.

There should be a couple 2 stars for each shoot. There should be very few 3 stars every couple months. I add a 4 star photo each 6 months or so. I have yet to make a 5 star photo. (I hope to someday.)

I also tend to add keywords for most photos but only if they are rated 2 stars or greater.

Using this system, you can easily create a smart collection to show off your best photos based for any occasion.

Pros: Makes it very easy to find your best photos and to create collections to print or share.

Cons: Takes a long time to implement, which makes it hard to be consistent.

Modified and Shorted Star System:

This is a blend of the first two systems. Use 1 star as you would the Pick Flag. Still use the reject flag. If you come back to a photo later and you happen to still really like it add a star. Think of adding a star like giving the photo another vote.

Pros: Still very easy to implement but you get a little more control to see you very best photos easily.

Cons: Not as much control as the full star system.


Find the system that works for you. Use collections, smart collections, folder and filters. Taking a couple minutes to think through your system will make organizing your photos in Lightroom much easier.